Responding to college student writing hampton, 1995. Straub challenges the dominant view that teacher commentary is directive or facilitative. The straub reaction was abolished by general anaesthesia with pentobarbitone or ether, by administration of tubocurarine, by bilateral section of the muscles causing extension to the tail, and by the removal of the circulation to the lower extremity. Richard straub is a orthopedic surgeon in derry, nh. Responding really responding to others students writing by richard straub this was by far my favorite article i read throughout the semester in english 1101.
Richard straub, orthopedic surgeon in derry, nh us news. Straub takes his article from a different approach by separating his essay into parts conveying what each reader needs to have to be a successful responder. Richard straub is founder and president of the peter drucker society europe and of the global peter drucker forum, which celebrated its 10th anniversary in 2018. Annotation to straubs responding really responding. He is telling the student to respond as a student and not to imitate the teacher. The distinction between reacting and responding is an important one and one i have emphasized in my psychotherapy and counseling practice. Straub, richard respondingreally responding to other.
I read this for enc1101 and it helped a lot of us feel more comfortable with workshopping with other people. One of the great examples he gives is to take a constructive but friendly approach. Richard straub s responding really responding to other student writings teaches readers how to consider and understand the right ways of responding to other people writings. I found it very helpful when he advised that you must take into account the circumstances of. Responding really responding to other students writing. Richard straub is an associate professor of english at florida state university. In this article responding really responding to other students,richard straub gave really good advises about giving a good feedback when looking at someone else paper. Implementing richard straubs responding really responding. Response to straubs respondingreally respondingto other. Reddit has thousands of vibrant communities with people that share your interests. Responding to other kudents writing richard straub richard straub taught courses in writing, rhetoric, and literature at florida state university. Really responding article pdf 17 responding\u2014really. Richard straubs responding really responding to other student writings teaches readers how to consider and understand the right ways of responding to other people writings. Straub responding really responding to other students writing richard straub 19562002 responding really responding to other students writing consider this.
Write most of your comments our in full statements. The essay give several options as to how to go about it as a general reader not as a friend who is trying to make the writer feel better about doing. Student workshops february 11, 2014 by prvico in preparation for a soon upcoming student workshop i was expected to read an article by richard straub titled responding really responding to other students writing. Pdf richard straubs guidelines for responding to student. In this article the author, richard straub, gives the audience guidance on how to properly read, evaluate and respond to student writing. I found it incredibly insightful to learn more about editing and responding to others writings. Youve got a student paper you have to read and make comments on for thursday. Richard straub, responding really responding to other students writing brock dethier, revising attitudes 2 course goals learning outcomes, eng 2100 and 2150. Straub respondingreally respondingto other students writing richard straub 19562002 respondingreally responding to other students writing consider this.
He taught courses in writing, composition and rhetoric, and literature at florida state. Sorting out three forms of judgment a sourcebook for responding to student writing. A model of teacher response, nancy sommers, and lil brannon and c. They discuss straub in small groups, and then after we watch the video i have them write reflectively for a few minutes in response to this prompt. Richard straubs guidelines for responding to student writing research pdf available october 2015 with 297 reads how we measure reads. Richard straubs respondingreally responding composition. Respondingreally respondingto other students writing. Richard straub is an associate professor of english at florida state university, where he teaches courses in writing, rhetoric and composition and literature. Richard straub is highly re garded for his outstanding scholarly work on responding to student writing. That is what my colleague richard straub and i did several years ago. Richard straubs responding really responding posted on september 8, 2010 by jsp10c i was fairly surprised by the writing of richard straubs responding really responding to other students writing, because of how forward he is with his suggestions on how to critique. Defining the varieties of directive and facilitative commentary n two pioneering articles in 1982, re sponding to student writing and on stu dents rights to their own texts. Seeking feedback from others and using it for revision.
I guess i had never put much thought into how to critique someones work before. Reddit gives you the best of the internet in one place. Sep 08, 2010 richard straubs responding really responding posted on september 8, 2010 by jsp10c i was fairly surprised by the writing of richard straubs responding really respondingto other students writing, because of how forward he is with his suggestions on how to critique. Whenever i would begin looking over another students paper, i would look at the name which was usually my friend. Richard straub s article responding really responding to other students writing shows a multitude of avenues when critiquing a piece of writing. This barcode number lets you verify that youre getting exactly the right version or edition of a book. In the practice of response, richard straub identifies seven different modes of. Richard straub gave good advice in responding really responding to other students writing. Key works on teacher response by richard straub, ronald. Feb 19, 2016 responding really responding to other students writing i found this weeks reading of responding really responding to other students writing by richard straub extremely interesting and helpful, especially considering the second assignment for this week. Responding really responding to students writing, richard straub let it be noted, in the forefront of this annotation, that this.
I think this is a good thing to do because it points out things throughout the paper that need to be fix or that are good point then at the end gives an overall rating of the paper at the end. I think he addresses an important issue with responding to papers because it seems like people never what to write to much on someones paper. He wrote numerous articles on response and published three books with hampton press. Corder, janice lauer, tilly warnock, elizabeth flynn, charles bazerman, and richard. Sep 27, 2012 responding really responding to students writing, richard straub let it be noted, in the forefront of this annotation, that this. One point i would like to see addressed in our writing workshop would be how to. Respondingto other kudents writing richard straub richard straub taught courses in writing, rhetoric, and literature at florida state university. Richard straub, respondingreally respondingto other students writing. Lunsford if one wants to know how best to respond to student writing, it would seem good to ask experts on composition theory what they do.
Responding to college student writing 1995, reports. Feb 11, 2014 richard straubs article responding really responding to other students writing shows a multitude of avenues when critiquing a piece of writing. In doing my research, i have found that scholars, like richard straub and frances zac, would argue that the response process happens before a teacher physically comments on a student paper. Get a constantly updating feed of breaking news, fun stories, pics, memes, and videos just for you.
Responding really responding to other students writing reading response in this article, richard straub, a professor at florida state university, gives the reader advice on how to improve the feedback procedure when overlooking someone elses paper. Straub takes his article from a different approach by separating his essay into parts where the reader will be successful. Respondingreally responding to other students writing. Richard straub is an associate professor of english at florida state. Prompts for straubs responding to other students writing. Straubs phone number, address, insurance information, hospital affiliations and more. In two pioneering articles in 1982, responding to student writing and. It examines the teacherresearchers responding practices in the full context of a. Key works on teacher response by richard straub, ronald lunsford. In this article responding really responding to other students, richard straub gave really good advises about giving a good feedback when looking at someone else paper. By richard straub, edited by ronald lunsford, unc charlotte theres a special threeway balance in responding to student writing. For straub, responding begins with the course description.
Respondingreally respondingto other students writing richard straub richard straub taught courses in writing, rhetoric, and literature at florida state university. Deborah brandt, sponsors of literacy tagged reading sandra cisneros, only daughter. His primary field was composition studies and his primary research interest was responding to student writing. As far as i am concerned, there is a significantand.
It begins with the assignment and the work in class. Types of response english teaching portal university of waterloo. Richard straub lives on the borders of tallahassee and teaches courses in writing. I feel like i applied a good response to when i reviwed alexis paper and i wouldnt change it after reading straub s responding really responding to other students. I found this weeks reading of responding really responding to other students writing by richard straub extremely interesting and helpful, especially considering the second assignment for this week. Download fulltext pdf richard straubs guidelines for responding to student writing research pdf available october 2015 with 297 reads. He starts out by saying exactly what everyone does, sliding by making a few comments and correcting gramatical errors, pointing out awkward sentences or fragments, just so you can move on with your life. Pdf richard straubs guidelines for responding to student writing. When i read about how we should be the reader, not the teacher, not the judge or critic, but simply the reader. Responding really responding to other students disneyland. The focus of much of his work is on reading, evaluating, and respondmg to student writing.
Straub gives ideas on what to look for, how to sound, and the goals to create when helping the writer. Straub outlines some ideas for what and what not to do when reading another writers paper, in particular. Archived moderator of rfsu1102y responding, really responding richard straub. In the text responding to other students writing by richard straub, straub encourages the reader of another persons work to take on the role of a fellow colleague that has the perfect balance between critiquing a work and complementing it. Sep 14, 2009 response to straubs respondingreally respondingto other students writing september 14, 2009 at 11. Pdf straub ideas, in terms of how teachers of writing respond to student writing, are really inspiring.
Respondinsreally respondingto other kudents writing. Alternatively, find out whats trending across all of reddit on rpopular. What management needs to become in an era of ecosystems. Wapp president richard straub called the meeting to order at 8.
Responding really responding to other students writing richard straub richard straub lives on the borders of tallahassee and teaches courses in writing, rhetoric, and literature at florida state university. Responding really responding to other students writing richard straub richard straub taught courses in writing, rhetoric, and literature at florida state university. He explains a good way in where to put the comments, how to comment using a good tone, and how to format the comments. In responding to other students writing, richard straub gives multiple suggestions on how to respond and edit other classmates work. He spent his academic career at florida state university, serving as assistant professor and later associate professor of english. Strategies for commenting on student writing 2000, a sourcebook on responding to. The reaction was modified by unilateral section of the extensor muscles of the tail. Professor richard straub, at florida state university writes an article explaining the dos and donts of responding to other students writing. Straub produces many significant tips and ideas to make a writing workshop extremely effective and beneficial. A specialist on reading, evaluating, and responding to student writing, he was from dunmore, pennsylvania. A sourcebook for responding to student writing by richard. Defining the varieties of directive and facilitative commentary. Richard straub the concept of control in teacher response. I was nervous because i didnt want to correct anything or step on anyones toes, but as the semester went on, we all got better with being honest with each other.
578 38 795 1521 969 1572 936 348 274 824 1524 241 272 789 1107 1289 1655 1314 225 219 1235 328 1222 1236 225 1095 810 198 151 905 875 1052 150 972 320 1084 1395 13 548 598 1342